Matching Methods for the Evaluation of Section 1115 Demonstrations

Matching Methods for the Evaluation of Section 1115 Demonstrations

Published: Feb 28, 2023
Publisher: Mathematica

Download

Associated Project

Supporting CMS Oversight of Medicaid 1115 Demonstrations

Time frame: 2019-2030

Prepared for:

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Center for Medicaid and CHIP Services

Authors

R. Vincent Pohl

Lianlian Lei

Matthew Niedzwiecki

States evaluating their section 1115 demonstration often use a comparison group design to estimate demonstration impacts. Ideally, these comparison groups have the same characteristics as the demonstration group, but this is usually not the case in practice. This white paper describes several matching methods states can use to make the comparison group more similar to the group affected by demonstration policies. These methods include propensity score matching and weighting which can be easily implemented using statistical software. It also provides a summary of best practices and guidelines for how states can explain their use of matching methods in evaluation designs and reports.

Efficiency Meets Impact.
That's Progress Together.

To solve their most pressing challenges, organizations turn to Mathematica for deeply integrated expertise. We bring together subject matter and policy experts, data scientists, methodologists, and technologists who work across topics and sectors to help our partners design, improve, and scale evidence-based solutions.

Work With Us