Early Childhood Educator Pay Equity Fund (PEF) Workforce Impact Study: Final Report
Download
Associated Project
Washington, DC Early Childhood Educator Pay Equity Fund Impact and Cost Effectiveness Study
Prepared for:
Bezos Family Foundation
Esther A. & Joseph Klingenstein Fund
DC Action
Early Care and Education Funders Collaborative
Washington Area Women's Foundation
Early Childhood Funders Collaborative
Clients
Key Findings
- After two years, the PEF increased hourly wages by $7.85 among retained center-based educators, meaning an annual wage increase of roughly $15,000 for a full-time worker. The program also increased wages among home-based providers. Differences in wage impacts across staff positions and qualifications were consistent with the program’s payment rules.
- The PEF increased center-based educator retention by 4.2 percentage points after one year and 4.8 percentage points after two years. Estimated effects on retention among home-based providers were larger but less precise. The PEF also increased facility recruitment by 12.5 percentage points after two years, with gains emerging during the second study year.
- Stronger retention and recruitment translated into 0.9 additional educators per center after one year and 1.4 after two years. Facility staffing gains occurred primarily in existing licensed capacity—suggesting that facilities used additional staff to fill staffing vacancies—and were concentrated in fewer operating centers after two years.
- Staff participating in the program were more likely to increase their highest education level and obtain associate’s, bachelor’s, and field-specific degrees while remaining with their facility, and PEF facilities employed larger shares of staff with college degrees after two years. The PEF increased promotion from assistant to lead teacher but produced suggestive evidence of decreased promotion from lead teacher to director.
The PEF is the nation’s first dedicated public funding stream designed to sustain large compensation increases across a local child care and early education sector. Launched in Washington, DC, in late 2022, the PEF initially provided fixed payments directly to eligible educators before transitioning to a facility payment model in fiscal year 2024 that incorporated minimum required salaries by educator role and qualifications into employer payrolls. The program also began providing access to subsidized health insurance in 2023.
This report estimates how the PEF affected participating center-based educators, licensed home-based providers, and center-based facilities during its first three years. The study linked population-level workforce registry records from Washington, DC, and six comparison states with PEF payment, licensing, child care subsidy, and quality-system administrative records. Using a quasi-experimental difference-in-differences design and propensity score weighting, the analysis estimated how outcomes for PEF participants would likely have changed in the absence of the program.
After two years, the PEF increased compensation in the amounts and patterns expected under the program’s design; strengthened staff attachment to their baseline facilities and facility workforce stability through retention and recruitment; and increased facility staffing primarily in existing licensed capacity, even as fewer centers remained open. It also improved staff and facility workforce qualifications, increased promotion odds within teaching positions, and may have increased facility engagement with public quality systems and the prevalence of high-quality ratings.
Together, the findings extend earlier evidence that the PEF increased sector employment by identifying the pathways through which those gains occurred. They show that large sustained public investment in child care and early education educator compensation can strengthen workforce retention, recruitment, staffing, and qualifications and underscored that effects depend on program design and broader policy context. The study also demonstrates how linked workforce registry records from multiple jurisdictions can support quasi-experimental evaluations of broadly implemented state and local child care and early education policies.
Efficiency Meets Impact.
That's Progress Together.
To solve their most pressing challenges, organizations turn to Mathematica for deeply integrated expertise. We bring together subject matter and policy experts, data scientists, methodologists, and technologists who work across topics and sectors to help our partners design, improve, and scale evidence-based solutions.
Work With Us